Competition rules · Referees, hantei, VAR

Refereeing and decision

Five referees judge every bout, and no decision stands without three votes. Here is how the decision is built, what the commands and flags mean, and what the video review introduced by the WKO 2026 rules adds.

§How many referees judge a bout?

Five: the main referee (shushin) and four corner judges (fukushin). An ippon, a waza-ari, a foul, a jogai or a decision is valid only when at least three of the five referees support it; the judgment of two referees or of the main referee alone does not stand. Each referee may object and ask for a discussion. The final decision on the competition rests with the chief referee.

EKO 2019Same principle: one referee (who gives the commands) and four judges, one vote each, majority of three; a discussion is requested through “fukushin shugo” and a video monitor may be used as a reference (art. 5.1 to 5.4).

Sources for this answer WKO 2026 — judging criteria, items 1 and 2 · EKO 2019 — art. 5.1–5.4, p. 6 · KDF 2026 — p. 1, items 1 and 2

§How is the decision (hantei) made without an ippon?

By order of priority. A waza-ari prevails first. Without a waza-ari, the damage suffered counts first. Without damage, the number of hand and foot techniques, including effective strikes. With equal numbers, fighting spirit (kihaku) decides — when one side must be chosen in the final extension. Warnings are then weighed under the decision criteria. The decision is valid with three votes out of five.

EKO 2019Same order (art. 8.9 to 8.14): waza-ari, damage, number of techniques (including yuko-waza), then the more active or more offensive contestant.

Karate Dream Festival 2026Detailed order: ippon > waza-ari > damage > yuko-da (effective techniques) > number of techniques > initiative (fighting spirit, moving forward, attacking first); in the final extension, dominance decides (pp. 2 and 5).

Sources for this answer WKO 2026 — section “Decision”; decision criteria, (2) · EKO 2019 — art. 8.9–8.14, p. 9; art. 14.3–14.5, pp. 11–12 · KDF 2026 — pp. 2 and 5

§What is the video review (VAR)?

New in the WKO 2026 rules. When a competitor goes down from an attack, or suffers comparable damage without falling, and three or more corner judges signal “miezu” (not seen), the main referee requests the video review; with two judges or fewer, the request is left to his judgment, and a judge may prompt him. The five referees may also request it together when it seems necessary. The chief referee and the supervisors examine the footage, shown on the big screen, and decide by majority. The VAR can establish an ippon, a waza-ari, a foul, a “not seen”, a false appeal or an excessive appeal. The main referee then explains the result to the arena, and the judges make the corresponding signal.

EKO 2019No VAR: only the video system provided by the organiser may be used, on the head referee's decision (art. 1.6), and a monitor may serve as a reference during a discussion (art. 5.4).

Karate Dream Festival 2026A monitor (video recording) may be used as a reference during discussions (p. 1, item 2).

Sources for this answer WKO 2026 — judging criteria, item 3 (VAR) · EKO 2019 — art. 1.6, p. 2; art. 5.4, p. 6 · KDF 2026 — p. 1

§What do the referee’s commands mean?

At the start: “shomen ni rei” (bow to the front), “shushin ni rei” (bow to the main referee), “otagai ni rei” (bow to each other), then “kamaete” (on guard) and “hajime” (begin). During the bout: “yame” (stop), “zokko” (continue), “time” (temporary stop of the clock). At the end: “hantei o torimasu” then “hantei” (the judges give their decision), “hikiwake” (draw), “ippon”, “shikkaku” (disqualification), “mitomezu” (not recognised).

EKO 2019Same commands (art. 17.5); “kamaete” is not compulsory if not needed; the clock is stopped by the command “jikan” (art. 7.1).

Sources for this answer WKO 2026 — kumite rules, 5 to 7; referee signals · EKO 2019 — art. 7.1, p. 8; art. 17.5, p. 14 · KDF 2026 — pp. 2 and 4

§What do the judges’ flag signals mean?

Ippon: the winner's flag raised diagonally upward, one loud, long whistle. Waza-ari: flag held horizontally, one loud whistle. Foul: the offender's flag waved up and down diagonally downward, short repeated whistles; both flags when both grab each other. Jogai: the flag taps the floor several times. Not seen: both flags crossed, one short whistle. Mitomezu: both flags crossed and waved, one long whistle. Decision: the winner's flag diagonally upward. Draw: both flags crossed in front of the knees. The main referee always counts the flags, including his own.

Sources for this answer WKO 2026 — referee signals, a) to k) · EKO 2019 — art. 17, pp. 14–19 · KDF 2026 — p. 4

§How does a bout end without an ippon?

At the end signal, the judges blow a long whistle; the main referee stops the bout with “yame”, has the competitors face the front and asks “hantei o torimasu”, “hantei”. Each judge raises the flag of the winner he chooses, or crosses the flags for a draw. The main referee announces the colour, counts the flags including his own — draws and flags for the other side are also counted — and declares the winner if there is a majority; otherwise he declares “hikiwake” and the bout goes to an extension or to the decision by weight.

Sources for this answer WKO 2026 — section “End of the bout” · KDF 2026 — p. 5 · EKO 2019 — art. 15, pp. 12–13 (variants of decisions)

Texts consulted

Every answer cites its text. The rulebooks belong to their organisations; when in doubt, the official document prevails.

  • WKO 2026 Regulation WKO Competition Rules (全世界空手道連盟 試合規約), revised edition of 29 July 2026 — Japanese text, unofficial translation Official document Official page
  • EKO 2019 Regulation EKO — Kumite Competition Regulation and Rules (17 March 2019) Official document
  • WKO 2026 Tournament document Karate Dream Festival 2026 International Championship — Kumite Competition Rules (WKO) Official document

Unofficial translation from Japanese (Claude, for the dojo, October 2026); the original text prevails.

From the rulebook to the mat.

Rules are there to be understood; the rest is learned at the dojo on Nuns’ Island, with a free first class.

Book a free trial class